Teachers Unions Protect Bad Teachers?

Teachers Unions Protect Bad Teachers

That’s the argument anyway: it’s impossible to get rid of bad teachers because teachers’ unions make it nearly impossible to fire them. Statistics say that it takes up to $219,000 to fire a bad teacher protected by tenure (http://teachersunionexposed.com/protecting.cfm).
But what makes a bad teacher? It’s not as easy a call as you might think.
Answering that question, an anonymous poster on a blog site wrote: “Great question! And I am a teacher. 1) Little or no sense of humor, and/or ability to laugh at oneself. 2)burnt out/uninspired/bored teachers. 3) Teachers w/ poor skills in communication, orginization, creativity. 4) judgemental teachers who are unable/unwilling to recognize their student’s strengths. 5) teachers who focus more on their student’s weaknesses. 6) those who do not differentiate their teaching styles/behavior management for individual students.7)those who simply do not care.  cold, uncaring teachers…..I could go on…. ” You can read other good opinions here: http://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/188300.page.
As you can surmise, determining bad teaching is a very subjective proposition. I remember one of my professors in college describing an eye-opening conversation with a public-school student. The professor had always considered himself to be a a pretty darn good teacher. The student had had a bad year with him and said, with great sincerity, “You are the worst teacher I’ve ever had.”
The professor’s point? A teacher may be good for some kids and not for others. Who says who’s bad? Disgruntled parents, unhappy about a bad grade, can put negative pressure to get rid of a teacher. A principal may just not like someone. A teacher struggling with depression or illness may have a few bad years. A struggling teacher may improve with help.
OTOH there really are bad teachers. I would say there are not very many of them. However, does it take dismantling teachers’ unions in order to remove them? What other approaches might we have?


The Way You Should Life: Discover better ways to create closer relationships, better health, increase wealth and learn tips on becoming the best person we can be. We will give detailed examples on how you can start living the life you always wanted, NOW.